Conley what makes a student college ready

Log in with Facebook Log in with Google. Remember me on this computer. Enter the email address you signed up with and we'll email you a reset link. Need an account?

Click here to sign up. Download Free PDF. Redefining College Readiness David T Conley. A short summary of this paper. Download Download PDF. Translate PDF. Redefining College Readiness David T. Redefining college readiness. The paper possess to be ready for college.

These suggests that, while much has been learned studies describe the need for students to about this phenomenon, particularly during understand how to apply to college, how to the past 20 years, few systematic attempts manage financial aid issues, and, perhaps have been made to integrate the various most importantly, how to adjust to college aspects or components of college readiness once they arrive.

The transition to college has that have been investigated in some depth a component of culture shock for students, during this period of time. As a result, college one that is more severe for students from readiness continues to be defined primarily some communities than others. Information in terms of high school courses taken and about the culture of college helps students grades received along with scores on national understand how to interact with professors and tests as its primary metrics.

Recent research has shed light on several key elements of college success. Examples of key key cognitive strategies general education course at a postsecondary include analysis, interpretation, precision and institution that offers a baccalaureate degree accuracy, problem solving, and reasoning.

Several proficiency that makes it possible for the studies have led to college readiness standards student to consider taking the next course in that specify key content knowledge associated the sequence or the next level of course in with college success.

Writing may be by far the the subject area. If students are prepared to behavioral attributes that students who succeed succeed in best practices courses, they will in college must demonstrate. Among these are be able to cope with the full range of college study skills, time management, awareness of courses they are likely to encounter.

These are both specific The college-ready student envisioned by skills and more general attitudes, but all of this definition is able to understand what is them require high degrees of self-awareness expected in a college course, can cope with the and intentionality on the part of students as content knowledge that is presented, and can they enter college.

Almost all of the rules of the designed to convey and develop. In addition, game that students have so carefully learned the student is prepared to get the most out and mastered over the preceding 13 years of of the college experience by understanding schooling are either discarded or modified the culture and structure of postsecondary drastically.

The pupil-teacher relationship education and the ways of knowing and changes dramatically as do expectations for intellectual norms of this academic and engagement, independent work, motivation, social environment.

The student has both the and intellectual development. All of this mindset and disposition necessary to enable occurs at a time when many young people this to happen.

No wonder that the transition from Uses of the Expanded Conception high school to college is one of the most of College Readiness difficult that many people experience during a lifetime. This definition can facilitate several important actions.

First and foremost, it can Because college is truly different be used to judge the current system widely in from high school, college readiness is place to gauge college readiness. The paper will fundamentally different than high school conclude that although measures exist currently competence.

Detailed analyses of college or are in the process of being developed to courses reveal that although a college course generate high quality information in all of the may have the same name as a high school component areas of the definition, no system course, college instructors pace their courses exists or is being developed to integrate the more rapidly, emphasize different aspects information and, more importantly, shape high of material taught, and have very different school preparation programs so that they do a goals for their courses than do high school better and more intentional job of developing instructors Conley et al.

Students student capabilities in all of these areas. The college instructor is more precision and across a wider range of variables likely to emphasize a series of key thinking and learning contexts and to provide better skills that students, for the most part, do information to high school students about not develop extensively in high school.

They their college readiness at key points in high expect students to make inferences, interpret school. Ideally and in addition, the definition results, analyze conflicting explanations can also be used as a conceptual framework to of phenomena, support arguments with design observational tools to assess the degree evidence, solve complex problems that have to which any particular high school program of no obvious answer, reach conclusions, offer instruction contains all the necessary elements explanations, conduct research, engage in to prepare students for college.

In short, a more the give-and-take of ideas, and generally robust, inclusive definition of college readiness think deeply about what they are being can help shape student behaviors and high taught National Research Council, Research findings describe college courses that require students to read eight to ten books in the same time that a high school class How College Is requires only one or two Standards for Success, Different from High School In these college classes, students write College is different from high school in multiple papers in short periods of time.

These many important ways, some obvious, some papers must be well reasoned, well organized, not so obvious. College Increasingly, college courses in all subject areas instructors are often mystified by such require well developed writing skills, research requests. The students are equally mystified by capabilities, and what have been commonly the instructor reaction, since this strategy has described as thinking skills.

In other words, the cultural According to the National Survey of and social expectations about learning and Student Engagement the vast majority performance that students encounter tend to of first-year college students are actively be vastly different as well.

They between high school and college are manifold are then expected to make presentations and significant. Students must be prepared to and to explain what they have learned.

In use quite a different array of learning strategies these courses, students are expected to and coping skills to be successful in college be independent, self-reliant learners who than those developed and honed in high recognize when they are having problems school. Current measures of college readiness and know when and how to seek help from do not necessarily capture well these many professors, students, or other sources.

At the same time, college faculty An important question to ask, based on consistently report that freshman students this assessment of the nature of college, need to be spending nearly twice the time is: How well do current measures gauge they indicate spending currently to prepare for student readiness along these and other class National Survey of Student Engagement, related important dimensions necessary for These students do not enter college with college success?

The next section describes a work ethic that prepares them for instructor the current means of determining college expectations or course requirements. College readiness and some of the limitations of those freshmen who are most successful are those approaches. This is followed by a section who come prepared to work at the levels that first defines a more comprehensive faculty members expect. Those who do not are notion of what it means to be college-ready much less likely to progress beyond entry-level and then details each of its facets.

Finally, the paper considers the changes Finally, the relationship between teacher necessary from high schools, colleges, and and student can be much different than in students for this new approach to be put high school. An oft-cited example by college into practice. This brief overview is presented particularly for students who attend high to accentuate the need for a more robust and schools with low academic standards and comprehensive definition of college readiness, expectations.

The nature and quality of one that leads to new tools, methods, and indices the courses students take are ultimately that will help students understand how ready what matters ACT, b , and few real for college they are and will help high schools measures of course quality exist currently. Each of the major measures and their set of criteria that specify the performances limitations is discussed briefly in turn. Since the s, states have centered their reform efforts around the development of Course Titles and statewide standards and assessments.

Yet Grade Point Averages most of these standards setting activities end at the 10th grade. Few states have The most common approach is to define undertaken to define 12th grade high school college readiness in terms of high school course standards and the curriculum necessary to taking patterns, including the titles, perceived attain those standards.

What school diploma have increased in a number this widely held definition assumes or presumes of states, they have yet to produce significant is that the number of courses that high school improvements in student performance in students take, and the units and names assigned college Achieve, Generally, these course Board, , but measures of college titles must be approved by college admissions graduation have not shown increases ACT, offices, in an uneasy but highly choreographed , a; Callan et al.

The scores improved significantly National Center net effect is to produce course titles that appear for Educational Statistics, More recently, data from of success in corresponding credit-bearing first- transcript analyses performed as a component of year college courses. This 2. This represented a. This is All states have adopted some form of particularly problematic because many colleges high school examination in English, math have raised their GPA requirements over the and science for a variety of reasons including same period of time Breland et al.

Research conducted by Standards Rather than leading to an improvement for Success, published in the report in student readiness for college, this appears Mixed Messages Conley, , found that simply to have resulted in the compression of most state standards-based high school tests grades at the upper end of the scale.

This has were not well aligned with postsecondary led to any number of attempts to compensate learning. These tests are perhaps good for the compression, primarily through the measures of basic academic skills, but not weighting of particular courses.

Individual high schools adopt their own on state tests may not be good indicators of weighting criteria, leading to myriad ways to college readiness, but students may believe compute a grade point average. When performance on state tests is requirements. Breland et al. In other words, it is very difficult to higher education institutions.

Tests This creates serious problems when high schools focus on getting students to pass Beyond using high school course titles to state tests. When students do finally pass the define college readiness, a more direct approach state exam, their program of study may be is to test a set of knowledge that students hopelessly out of sequence with what it takes are presumed to need to know to succeed to be college eligible.

One possible means to in college entry-level courses. The California State University system, high school exam score. The rates at community colleges are likely some assumptions might be made about what much higher, leading to multi-tier remediation a student who takes a class has learned.

This is programs at some institutions where student skill because each AP course has a set of curricular levels are so low they must take more than one and resource requirements and, often more remedial course in a subject area before reaching a importantly, because many students take the credit-bearing course.

This causes teachers to align course content with Having to enroll in remedial courses the curricular and exam specifications. These issues with AP courses Children from low-income families are demonstrate how even an externally-referenced particularly vulnerable to a system that does program such as AP can be co-opted to serve the not send clear signals to students on how purpose of inflating the academic credentials ready they are for college.

These families can only gauge how ready for Performance in College Courses college success their children are based on An obvious but frequently overlooked fact the measures used by the schools. They are is that the final arbiter of college readiness among the most likely to end up in remedial is student performance in college courses.

Those students who do succeed in earning a college degree are taking The high proportion of students who are longer to do so now than 20 years ago ACT, Just some of these courses approach 50 percent, and as important, this suggests that the high school while some argue this is the fault of poor college program of preparation is not adequately geared teaching, others argue that this failure rate can toward expecting these students to be prepared be explained equally by poor study habits, a for college admission or success.

These students lack of understanding of the expectations of are subjected to considerably lower expectations college instructors, and deficiencies in content and demands in courses with titles that satisfy the knowledge and thinking skills.

These the iceberg. Many institutions allow students standards are not geared to what should or to choose not to take remedial courses even does occur in high schools as much as to what if the student is identified as needing such a will be expected of students in college. Placement methods vary tremendously from institution to institution and are often No less than a half-dozen such sets of rudimentary in nature, identifying only those standards exist currently at the national and students with the most serious deficiencies.

They largely concur on what These factors in combination result in many students need to know and be able to do to be students, particularly students from low- ready for college. All are focused expectations income families and firstgeneration college attendant with entry-level college courses. Washington, D. Achieve, Inc. Its goal General Education was to develop standards that reflected both college and work readiness in mathematics and Student performance in general education English Achieve, Both the College Board courses has long been an issue in postsecondary and ACT have published their own versions education, where these courses come to serve as of college readiness standards and criteria.

In the real arbiter of admission. In order to provide the interconnectedness of all of the facets a functional representation of the key facets contained in the model. This is the key point of college readiness, the model presented of this definition, that all facets of college below organizes the key areas necessary readiness must be identified and eventually for college readiness into four concentric measured if more students are to be made levels.

These four areas of college readiness college-ready. Key Cognitive Strategies In practice, these various facets are not The success of a well-prepared college mutually exclusive or perfectly nested as student is built upon a foundation of key key portrayed in the model.

They interact with cognitive strategies that enable students to one another extensively. For example, a lack of learn content from a range of disciplines.

Those that do contain performance tasks are severely limited in the time the tasks can take and their breadth or depth. Several studies of college faculty members nationwide, regardless of the selectivity of the university, expressed near-universal agreement that most students arrive unprepared for the intellectual demands and expectations of postsecondary Conley, a. The student compares and contrasts sources In other words, key cognitive strategies are and findings and generates summaries and patterns of intellectual behavior that lead to explanations of source materials.

They Interpretation: The student analyzes include the following as the most important competing and conflicting descriptions manifestations of this way of thinking: of an event or issue to determine the Intellectual openness: The student possesses strengths and flaws in each description curiosity and a thirst for deeper and any commonalities among or understanding, questions the views of distinctions between them; synthesizes others when those views are not logically the results of an analysis of competing supported, accepts constructive criticism, or conflicting descriptions of an event and changes personal views if warranted or issue or phenomenon into a coherent by the evidence.

Such openmindedness explanation; states the interpretation that helps students understand the ways in is most likely correct or is most reasonable, which knowledge is constructed, broadens based on the available evidence; and personal perspectives and helps students presents orally or in writing an extended deal with the novelty and ambiguity often description, summary, and evaluation of encountered in the study of new subjects varied perspectives and conflicting points and new materials.

Inquisitiveness: The student engages in active Precision and accuracy: The student knows inquiry and dialogue about subject matter what type of precision is appropriate to and research questions and seeks evidence the task and the subject area, is able to to defend arguments, explanations, or increase precision and accuracy through lines of reasoning.

These findings have been confirmed in requiring method-based problem solving. This is followed by brief endeavor of the university.

They are necessary narrative descriptions of content from a number to discern truth and meaning as well as to of core academic areas. They are at the heart of how postsecondary faculty members think, and how they think about their subject areas. Without the Overarching Academic Skills capability to think in these ways, the entering Writing: Writing is the means by which college student either struggles mightily until students are evaluated at least to some these habits begin to develop or misses out on degree in nearly every postsecondary the largest portion of what college has to offer, course.

Expository, descriptive, and which is how to think about the world. Academic Knowledge and Skills Students are expected to write a lot in college and to do so in relatively short Successful academic preparation for periods of time.

Students need to know college is grounded in two important how to pre-write, how to edit, and how dimensions—key cognitive strategies to re-write a piece before it is submitted and content knowledge. Understanding and, often, after it has been submitted and mastering key content knowledge is once and feedback has been provided.

With this relationship in each point, and utilize the basics of a mind, it is entirely proper and worthwhile to style manual when constructing a paper. Most of the schools made college real to their students through visitation programs, dual enrollment courses, and opportunities for their students to take college courses.

In all cases, the high schools supported students who were engaged in these activities. The goal of this project was to identify common effective practices for getting a wider range of students ready for college. We have synthesized our findings into a self-evaluation tool—the College Readiness Evaluation for Students and Teachers—which will help high schools determine how well they are addressing the four dimensions of college readiness.

Schools do the self-evaluation by having teachers, counselors, and administrators complete an online instrument. This input generates a report listing the areas in which the school could improve college readiness practices, an explanation of why the highlighted areas are important, and which activities the school should undertake first.

Also included are links to a range of proven resources that the school can use to get started on an improvement plan. The self-evaluation tool is being field tested during the —09 school year. By learning from a set of best-practice high schools, all high schools can begin to move in the right direction, emphasizing the knowledge, skills, dispositions, programs, and practices necessary for all students to be successful in postsecondary educational settings.

American Diploma Project. Ready or not: Creating a high school diploma that counts. Washington, DC: Achieve, Inc. College readiness standards. Iowa City, IA: Author. College Board. Standards for college success. New York: Author. Conley, D. Understanding university success. Texas Higher Education Coordinating Board. Texas college readiness standards. Austin, TX: Author. David T. Conley has contributed to Educational Leadership.

What Makes a Student College Ready? End Notes. Learn More. Want to add your own highlights and notes for this article to access later? Become a member today. Related Articles View all. School Culture. Professional Learning. Collective Efficacy or Toxic Positivity?

Related Articles. Knowing something about what students want to do in college is important to understanding how ready they are. Not all students need exactly the same knowledge and skills to succeed.

The undecided student clearly needs a strong foundational set of skills in English and math. Students with defined interests may need to augment those foundational skills in certain ways, or may be able to overcome shortcomings in an area not central to their aspirations with added strengths in areas that are central to achieving their academic and career goals. This more nuanced and complex approach to readiness is not easily mandated through a uniform set of policies regarding remediation or cut scores.

It requires much greater involvement by everyone involved in and affected by the readiness, admissions, and placement processes. Increasingly, the expectation is the ability to formulate a problem in the first place, and then solve it; to collect the information necessary to formulate the problem and pursue its solution; to distinguish the credibility, validity, and value of source information; to collect enough information from a wide enough range of sources; to interpret all of that information intelligently and with a value-added component, and then to communicate the resulting synthesis in the most appropriate format from among many options.

Few teachers and students define research in this fashion. Libraries and librarians can clearly play a crucial role in helping students and teachers understand this new research paradigm. In particular, they can help teachers develop assignments whereby students must first formulate the problem before attempting to solve it. The formulation process involves hypothesis generation and examination, which in itself requires examining a wider range of options before reaching a conclusion about the nature of the problem and the specific type of strategy best suited to solve it.

Similarly, when searching for source material, students need to be making many more decisions about the type of material necessary to solve the problem as formulated and the value and quantity of the sources they locate. How much information at what level of credibility and validity is necessary based on the nature of the problem at hand? These types of more sophisticated forms of analysis help learners develop the skills they will need in college and careers.

They also help teachers develop better assignments going forward. They were relieved to be free of rigid high school curricula and excited by the prospect of diving into research on topics they found more interesting.

At the same time, however, they were overwhelmed at the prospect of sorting through and comprehending the voluminous amount of information available to them. Why do so many freshmen lack the cognitive strategies needed to conduct college-level research? How many high school students ever even see something like that as a tool to help them understand what the inquiry process consists of? Keep in mind that even our highest achieving students generally just follow directions and do what they are asked to do.

My research indicates that high school students write very few research papers, and when they do, they might write one or perhaps two long papers, which their instructors feel represent what students need to know how to do in college. In fact, analyses that my colleagues at the Educational Policy Improvement Center EPIC in Eugene and Portland, Oregon, have found is that college courses and career training programs tend to expect students to complete lots of shorter assignments, in the page range for college courses in particular.

High school students do not get much experience developing tightly organized, well structured, and thoroughly referenced papers or presentations of this nature. Instead, they may learn to write a six-paragraph essay based on the requirements of the state testing program or to prepare for the SAT or ACT writing sections. This type of formulaic writing does not in any way prepare students to undertake the more complex work they will encounter in college and many career-training programs.

As far as students asking for help, here, again, studies about students are informative. In fact, students most in need of help tend to be least likely to ask for it, for several reasons.