Why does m1 garand ping

Soldiers have only recently begun to wear any kind of hearing protection at all, which would have made such a noise even more difficult to detect. Not to mention the obvious fact that soldiers rarely fight alone. At all but the closest ranges, this really is a myth and a total non-issue.

Canfield has done online, in no uncertain terms. However, this situation is more complicated than just the bare facts. Sometimes, myths intrude into reality by being thoroughly embedded in thought and practice. Half the men had a nagging fear that some day the noise made in releasing the safety would reveal their positions to the enemy, yet only one-fourth objected to the distinctive noise the empty clip made when ejected. They were quite willing to retain the noise of the clip even though the enemy might be able to use it to advantage, because they found it a very useful signal to reload.

Helpful to know when to reload, therefore retain — But the answers speak for themselves. Of those soldiers surveyed, twice as many believed that the noise was helpful to the enemy, as thought it unimportant. Thus it is felt that the results are reliable and can be fairly said to represent what the infantryman believed he did.

The fact that these were group interviews further increased the reliability of the results, since any apparent exaggeration by one man was quickly picked up and questioned by others.

Now tell me about how you are going to be able to take advantage of hearing the M-1 ping? He chalks up the story to the power of myths and legends soldiers tell in order to give meaning to their experiences.

Which is one way that a legend becomes a fact … at least in the eyes of many scholars and old soldiers. Did the classic Garand rifle have a fatal flaw that told the enemy you were out of ammo? Hornady grain M1 Garand ammo.

Then you push the sheet metal en bloc clip loaded with eight. It probably resulted in more than one military man getting killed since it signaled the gun was empty. But the M-1 proved its worth, making it one of the most popular weapons … ever. Posted On August 11, This was a drawback of using that type of "clip". But Patton knew a thing or two about killing — and he knew that in the hands of Allied troops the Garand did its share of killing. Additionally, it possesses qualities beloved by all troops.

If a can also shoot 45's, can a 28 gauge shoot 50 caliber? It solved the problem using a box magazine with no "ping". Army trained. The last round fired ejects the clip. Second, soldiers typically fight as a group, so the G. Pictured: A bunch of Marines on Iwo Jima not fighting on their own. Photo: US Marine Corps. Out of responders, 85 thought that the ping was helpful to the enemy, but a whopping thought it was more useful to the shooter by acting as a useful signal to reload. Petrie after he reportedly spoke to German veterans of D-Day who found the idea of attacking after a ping laughable.